China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 vs KBP Instrument Design Bureau Pantsir-S1
China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 and KBP Instrument Design Bureau Pantsir-S1 are both air defense system, compared here on public specifications. The China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 leads on engagement range (200 vs 20 km). Several China and Russia-origin figures here are manufacturer or state claims with limited independent verification, so treat this comparison as directional.
Compare systems side by side
Search above to add up to five systems. You’ll get a per-spec winner, relative bars, a normalized spec profile and an honest verdict, every number from public sources.
Building a fleet? Try the Force Builder →
Full data
Full spec sheet
 China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9
Wins 6/7 |  KBP Instrument Design Bureau Pantsir-S1
Wins 1/7 | |
|---|---|---|
| Performance | ||
| Max speed (Mach) (Mach) | 4.2 Mach ✓ | 3 Mach |
| Engagement range (km) | 200 km ✓ | 20 km |
| Engagement altitude (m) | 27,000 m ✓ | 15,000 m |
| Simultaneous targets | 6 ✓ | 4 |
| Firepower | ||
| Warhead (kg) | 180 kg ✓ | 20 kg |
| Sensors & avionics | ||
| Radar range (km) | 300 km ✓ | 36 km |
| Program | ||
| Unit cost (USD) | N/A | $15,000,000 |
| Operator countries | 3 | 8 ✓ |
Frequently asked questions
Which has the longer engagement range? +
The China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 has the longest engagement range at 200 km.
Which is cheaper? +
The KBP Instrument Design Bureau Pantsir-S1 has the lower public unit-cost figure at 15,000,000 USD. Treat this as directional, defense pricing varies by contract and configuration.
Which has the higher max speed (mach)? +
The China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 has the higher max speed (mach) at 4.2 Mach.
Which has the higher simultaneous targets? +
The China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 has the higher simultaneous targets at 6.
Which has the higher warhead? +
The China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 has the higher warhead at 180 kg.
Which has the higher engagement altitude? +
The China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 has the higher engagement altitude at 27,000 m.
Is the China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 better than the KBP Instrument Design Bureau Pantsir-S1? +
On the public specs we track, the China Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation HQ-9 leads on 6 of 6 headline metrics, see the full spec sheet for the metric-by-metric breakdown.
Where does this comparison data come from? +
Every figure in the table is sourced from public manufacturer pages, defense-ministry releases and reference publications, and is verifiable on each system's spec page. WeaponSpecs does not accept vendor placement.
Keep exploring
